What kind of Polyglot are you?
- So to what level should I speak a language in order for it to count?
- How diverse should the languages be?
- So how many languages does one have to speak to become a polyglot?
- So what do we call people who go well beyond 4 languages?
- So what about people who learn to speak an incredible number of languages?
So to what level should I speak a language in order for it to count?
Obviously speaking a language should be more than simply being able to order in a restaurant. Using the Common European Framework of Reference for Languages (CEFR), B2 level is approximately the minimum to be able to say that you ‘speak’ a language. The CEFR describes B2 level as an “independent user” with the following competences in reading, listening, speaking and writing:
How diverse should the languages be?
Languages are organized into families and then into family branches, e.g. the Indo-European language family has a Germanic branch of which English, German and Dutch are members. Within family branches familiarity with one language normally makes it a lot easier to understand and learn the other languages within the same family branch. Therefore, within polyglot categories there should be a minimum amount of linguistic family variety, i.e. that not all languages are from one or two family branches.
So how many languages does one have to speak to become a polyglot?
As the root of the word only means ‘many’ then one could argue that just by being multilingual, one is a ‘polyglot’. However, in popular imagination ‘polyglot’ has come to mean something more than just a few. Being a ‘polyglot’ can certainly arise from living in a country where just by living there obliges you to be multilingual, e.g., Luxembourg, India and parts of Africa, in particular. For this reason, I would say that one should speak a minimum of 4 languages in order to describe oneself as a ‘polyglot’.
So what do we call people who go well beyond 4 languages?
In his book, ‘Babel no more’, Michael Erard argues that a ‘hyperpolyglot’ is someone who speaks 11 or more languages because he thought that’s where language learning gets ‘interesting’. Previously, Richard Hudson had argued that 6 or more languages made someone a ‘hyperpolyglot’ because there are societies where it is normal for people to speak 5 languages (as per the examples cited above). However, if we take the case of Luxembourg, a child of immigrants, say from Portugal, should grow up without much additional effort to speak Luxembourgish, Portuguese, French, German, Dutch and English. Therefore, a category that I will call ‘superpolyglot’ should be these 6 languages plus one, i.e. 7 or more. Also the languages should come from a minimum of 2 language family branches. Renowned superpolyglots who come to mind are Steve Kaufmann, Benny Lewis, Susanna Zaraysky, Stu Jay Raj and Olly Richards.
So what about people who learn to speak an incredible number of languages?
There is an exclusive level that few language learners achieve. While the 11+ of ‘hyperpolyglottism’ set by Erard is a big milestone for language learners, some polyglots go significantly further. That said it is relatively rare for even top language learners to speak 20+ languages so a new benchmark for this level should be the highest accolade. This new category is ‘ultrapolyglottism’, a level above ‘hyperpolyglottism’. The languages should come from a minimum of 5 language family branches in the ‘ultrapolyglottism’ category. A high competency in so many languages is very difficult to maintain as one´s time to use or learn the languages is spread out over more and more languages. Examples of these rare ultrapolyglots could be Richard Simcott, Alexander Arguelles, Emanuele Marini and Ioannis Ikonomou.
The level to which historical figures such as Mezzofanti and Krebs spoke their amazing number of languages is sadly impossible to verify today. Maintaining such a huge number of languages to such a high level is an almost superhuman feat. 20 languages is around the upper limit for what has been demonstrated on video by YouTube polyglots in the last few years since they started uploading their videos. Verifying their levels in each language would be vital in ascertaining where the upper limits in language learning lie at this point in time.